October 22, 2015 at 4:45 am #17723
I know this forum isn’t very active, but I thought I’d post anyway. I’ve been wanting to lose a little weight (I gained 4kgs from RRARF and another 4kgs pregnancy weight that hasn’t dropped off yet, my baby is 8 months old).
A friend and I decided to try the I Quit Sugar 8 week program (basically a book about how fructose is evil, etc. etc.). Now having read Matt’s stuff I was reluctant to get back into a “xyz food group is evil” mindset, but, I did also realize that I was drinking massive amounts of fruit juice every day and eating a lot of jams, so if there is any truth to the fructose = fat gain thing I thought I’d experiment. Another factor was that I was consuming the fruit juice, jam etc. for quick energy instead of eating real food balanced meals, so wanted to break that habit.
I pretty much gave up all fructose (including sucrose) cold turkey straight away. In the first two weeks the following happened:
1. My appetite dropped massively for a week, I’d say about half of what it was. I’m breastfeeding (weaning) so this actually worried me a bit. By the second week, my appetite seemed a bit more normal.
2. I lost 1.5kgs but don’t seem to be losing any more.
3. My milk production is a abundant as ever, I actually still have a bit of an over supply (enough to donate some to a newborn who was having some feeding issues). My baby is as content as ever (she’s a big happy chunk), in fact she might even be a little bit less gassy.
4. I quit sugar (sucrose) but replaced it with dextrose (in tea, occasional baking etc.) because I wasn’t willing to give up all sweet things. Not sure how I feel about dextrose, it gives me a great quick energy boost/sweet hit but tastes a bit…powdery. It’s ok in something like breakfast muffins though that don’t need to be very sweet.
5. At first, I didn’t crave fruit/juice at all or miss them, but I’ve found that I’m starting to want that sweet/sour combo you get in fruit occasionally. I’ve eaten the odd apple or pear and satisfied that.
6. My tastes buds changed within a few days and I seem to taste the sweetness of non-sweet foods more, I like this effect as it has made meals seem more enjoyable, I seem to be enjoying the combination of sweet and savory flavors, like mashed sweet potato with a gravy rich mushroom pie. I wasn’t a big fan of sweet potatoes before, they seemed too much like a “health food” :D
I think cutting out fruit juice has been good for my health because I’m eating more real food instead, but I’m not convinced cutting out sucrose has had any benefits, I think a small amount of it does me good so will probably allow some back in, dextrose on oatmeal just isn’t the same as nice melting brown sugar crystals.
But, if this actually works for weight loss, it has been easy for me to do because I don’t actually like fruit particularly, and was only drinking fruit juice out of habit, so it has been a good way to reduce calories slightly without feeling hungry.
In terms of metabolism, I still feel warm and toasty most of the time. My personal metabolism check is to see how easily my hair falls out, if I don’t notice hair loss then I feel all is good.
Sorry for the ramble, just enjoying documenting this little experiment :)
October 22, 2015 at 5:13 am #17725
- This topic was modified 8 years, 4 months ago by Rosie123.
p.s. we started the 8 week fructose free thing 4 weeks ago, so have another 4 weeks to do.November 1, 2015 at 12:59 pm #17726
Just thought I’d update this in case anyone is actually following! I went 4 weeks with no obvious sources of fructose (sugar, juice, fruits, honey), just some occasional dextrose for sweetness.
An interesting thing happened after just over 4 weeks of doing this, I went from not feeling particularly bothered about the lack of sugar in my diet (I didn’t crave it particularly) to waking up suddenly with massive sugar cravings, particularly for Kitkats – I haven’t eaten a Kitkat for about 10 years so this was odd!
I figured my body is telling me I need sugar, so I had some real sugar on cornflakes, had a piece of cake and some chocolate, and found that the Kitkat craving finally went away and I felt rather happy and well :) I had a few days of eating more sugar than is my normal habit, but my sugar cravings have settled back to something acceptable. I now don’t think sugar is addictive necessarily, if it were, surely I’d spiral into a sugar binge frenzy needing more and more rather than having a bit extra then feeling “ok, that was enough sugar for now”.
So my month of no fructose/sugar resulted in:
1. about 1.5kgs of weight loss (nothing spectacular).
2. a kind of taste-bud reset, making everything taste sweeter than usual (that was kind of cool).
3. A few weeks of feeling kind of blah… not really tired, but not massively motivated either. Everything just felt kind of boring. I didn’t realize how much so until I had some sugar and felt like my brain/moods/energy got revitalized and suddenly life seemed interesting :D. I’m guessing this is something to do with dopamine?
After this, I don’t have much interest in quitting sugar, while it was nice to have a little weight loss, it isn’t worth it if the cost is feeling kind of blah and unmotivated. I think I’ll stay off the fruit juice for a while though, as I think it’s been better for me to eat more actual food instead.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.