Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Rob
ModeratorSince there seems to be some interest in this topic, maybe next month I’ll do my follow up to my calorie experiment and how it’s going for me. I was planning to wait a while longer just to establish and observe long term trends, but a 6 month update from my post might still be useful.
What do you think Matt and newsletter readers? I can also start to write about my experience so far with Garrett Smith’s hair mineral analysis stuff, as I began that around four months ago.
Rob
ModeratorChange always comes with a period of disruption. Sorry everyone.
Here’s the thing: the blog represented the period of active investigation that was ongoing for years. That has been winding down for some time, as some commenters have pointed out, and even Matt has in some of his posts and guest posts (such as ‘Nutrition in Three Words’) said as much. There’s an infinite number of things to say on the topics covered here, but most of them are not all that helpful and can be distilled to a much smaller, more focused set of ideas. That’s what this is about.
You guys don’t see how much goes on in the back end replying to people’s questions and comments and trying to get everyone on the same page. And still it doesn’t always work because there’s confusing material out there and many people end up never bothering to read more as a result
Not everyone has time to scour the archives and see the seven year evolution. By paring things down, we can offer the best stuff that Matt can stand behind and feel confident in. You still get Matt’s writing and his insight, but we get to offer it with the benefit of some hindsight. And a clean slate allows us to build from the start rather than go through hundreds of old posts and attempt to remove incongruences and bring them up to date.
EDIT: Also, for those of you who follow 180, you can get all the material that Matt stands by for FREE. We just will now be able to avoid hosting stuff that no longer makes sense. Newbies will know where we’re coming from and know where to start and regulars continue to get free material, and can continue to share and communicate here on the forums.
Rob
ModeratorHey everyone,
Yes, the blog is no more. As we wrote in the Facebook group, blogs are subject to confusion, especially with the many changes of orientation 180 has seen over the years.
Right now, half the people who visit the site each day are new. When they read that pizza and ice cream are good for you and don’t have the context to put that in, how many of them do you think stay? How many people do we lose because they write this crazy guy off, and as a result, they never learn enough to benefit from any insight here?
I get emails all the time from people who point out old articles and don’t know how to reconcile it with the newer material, and it’s a lot of work to orient each person. They don’t necessarily know where to start or what to make of the material on site.
The idea here is to get everyone on the same page, literally, and consolidate the best of the material, the most persistent and useful info, all the key posts and points, without old left behind ideas clouding the helpful information.
Now everyone will get a full course, basically, in the 180D approach. You get information sequentially in a way that builds upon itself but doesn’t require you to go back to the very start of the archives in 2006 and filter out the abandoned information, and grapple with excess cognitive dissonance.
As time has gone on, the importance of the basics has really come to the fore, and we can present that in detail. Basic ideas like attention to your food and fluid patterns, and avoiding extreme regiments, and cultivating mindfulness and instinctual choices can be given the attention they need, while diversions like carb cycling or fructose avoidance or maximum nutrient partitioning are not emphasized.
The goal continues to be to make this information as usefully available as possible, and keyword here is *usefully.* Having a hundred different ways for people to discount what’s written here (even if it was just a part of a long-standing investigative exploration and was later abandoned), does not accomplish that. Streamlining things so people know what we’re about does.
There were other ancillary site related reasons, such as the fact that too many comments allegedly shut the place down a week or two back. We lost the old comment structure and the replacement was not as simple to use, and there wasn’t much we could do about it according to our web developer. Coupled with all of the above reasons, extracting the best material and providing the right framework for it to actually be helpful and useful for readers led to this decision.
Hopefully you see a bit more what we’re trying to accomplish here, and we’ll do our best to make this next phase fun for everyone.
Rob
Moderator15lbs of lean gains for a total novice on a good program with good nutrition is conceivable, though it would be on the high end.
Not sure about cooked versus raw proteins. My instinct screams to be skeptical, but who knows? I’m not particularly motivated to investigate further, though. If you do, feel free to report back any insight.
September 23, 2013 at 1:03 pm in reply to: Raise your hand if you think being intelligent sucks! #12768Rob
ModeratorPost title made me think of this video. :-D
Rob
ModeratorI’ve heard anecdotally that women often do less well fasting.
And I’m no shill for IF. But I’m also skeptical of articles that boldy declare IF as a cause of diabetes. But who knows? Chronic stress hormone elevation does seem to be at work in diabetes and can be instigated (or exacerbated by) paleo/IF eating.
Rob
ModeratorHere’s an article about Improving Glucose Clearance on site.
The short version is: improve metabolic rate through quality sleep, ample calories (especially carbs), prefer saturated over unsaturated fats, engage in sensible and sustainable exercise that you enjoy, and reduce stress. Also, pay attention to when you have bouts of ‘low blood sugar’ and act quickly to intercept them with something salty/carby like some crackers or dried fruit or something, and avoiding fluids. By keeping the body from ‘crashing,’ you avoid activating the stress hormone system and keep the body in a pro-metabolic place where blood sugar issues are uncommon.
Over time, by supporting the body and improving metabolic rate, glucose clearance improves, and blood sugar normalizes.
Rob
ModeratorHey Nira,
Didn’t see this below. Sounds like a great topic and solid research. Once you have a new flow chart up, email me rob at 180degreehealth and maybe we can feature it on site.
Hope all’s well
Rob
ModeratorVery possibly. When the body is in a hypometabolic state, the tendency toward edema (water retention) is much higher.
As you get healthier, you’ll likely find that this issue subsides. Though based on all sorts of factors, everyone does have some daily fluctuations in weight and water retention.
Rob
ModeratorHas anything changed for you recently? Work? Home life? Stress? Dietary changes? Seasonal changes maybe?
Often sleep disturbances happen in conjunction with other stuff going on.
September 23, 2013 at 12:19 pm in reply to: Anyone have experience with typical bodybuilding supplements? #12762Rob
ModeratorI’ve actually been using a different routine the last month and a half or so. 4X/week upper lower split, only SLDL along with squats, with chins and DB rows for back.
I reckon you may have been right. That could have been a bit much.
What’s your routine like these days?
Rob
ModeratorI doubt the dude gained 15kg of muscle in a year. That’s over 30lbs, and unless he was an absolute beginner and had exceptional response/recovery/nutrient partitioning, and maybe was going through a growth spurt, those sorts of gains are almost impossible absent enhancements (steroids or other PEDs).
Another possibility is that he had previous trained to that weight, lost it, and then regained it quickly due to muscle memory.
That said, I think a quality rice protein supplement like Garden of Life’s raw protein would be a good option for a vegan trying to put on muscle. In a hyper-caloric diet, protein needs go way down, as the body uses the protein very efficiently in caloric abundance. IN a hypocaloric diet, protein seems much more necessary for lean mass retention.
Here’s a post from Matt about how much protein one needs, that might be of some help.
Rob
ModeratorNo way dude, you’re not an asshole. You can be crass and maybe a little ribald, but it’s in good humor.
Plus you’re a frequent voice of reason when some of us, myself included, get caught up in a new idea or perspective and go gung ho. The ‘exercise to lose weight’ thread being a good example. Rather than the conversation become an echo chamber of ‘yeah, exercising to look good naked is dumb,’ you offered a good nuanced counter-point.
Anyway, appreciate all your contributions man. Be glad to see you stick around in whatever capacity fits for you
Rob
Moderator1) Also skeptical. Probably exists in some people and in some fashion, but it may be just a useful catch-all attempt to put a name to people being in bad shape.
2) I also had my metal fillings removed, and took epsom salt baths for a few months afterward. Seemed to help a bit, but it wasn’t the cure-all I imagined it would be in my case.
3) A bit more skeptical of vaccines, though I don’t know if they cause autism. I do think researching the timing of vaccinations is valuable; my cursory understanding is that kids are receiving more vaccines at an earlier age than even twenty years ago, and their bodies may not be well-equipped for managing that. Spacing it differently could help. When I have kids, I’m sure I’ll research pretty heavily.
4) No idea, but anecdotally, almost no one I know has been impacted by it, except me, when I convinced myself that I ought to cut out the carbs to starve it out. Turns out, I just needed to eat and sleep more and take better care of myself to deal with my low energy levels.
5) I re-read Go Kaleo’s article here recently. Her point is that many of the symptoms of adrenal fatigue mirror those of starvation. Often just ensuring adequate calories and rest is enough to see those symptoms disappear.
6) Haven’t looked into them much. No thoughts really.
August 22, 2013 at 2:40 pm in reply to: What do you use for insomnia? I am dying of sleep deprivation! #11932Rob
Moderator@ThomasSeay – Saw that too, and thought, lol. Also, first time poster, dozen+ bullet points, lots of outside links, no obvious points of reference to 180. Spammy? Nah, seems legit.
Still, many of the suggestions aren’t bad. Flux is a cool program, for example, and I’m down with sunlight and walking on the grass.
-
AuthorPosts